Subscribe
INSIGHT ON ADJUDICATION ORDER 21 October 2025 3 min read

ROC Delhi Order on Section 10A Penalty: What Went Wrong and Lessons for Compliance Professionals

ROC Delhi penalized Tejas Cargo India Ltd for availing a commercial loan before filing INC-20A. The case highlights Section 10A compliance requirements under the Companies Act 2013 and offers key lessons on avoiding procedural defaults in post-incorporation stages.

PK
CS Prashant KumarCompany Secretary | Compliance Professional
Share:
ROC Delhi penalised Tejas Cargo India Ltd for exercising borrowing powers before filing Form INC-20A.
Need help with this?

Talk to us about policies, filings and implementation for your entity.

Contact Us

Case Summary

Company: Tejas Cargo India Limited

Default: The company availed a commercial vehicle loan from HDFC Bank before obtaining the Certificate of Commencement of Business (INC-20A).

Relevant Section: Section 10A(1) and (2) of the Companies Act, 2013
Penalty Provision: ₹50,000 on company + ₹1,000 per day (up to ₹1 lakh) on each officer in default

Penalty Imposed: ₹50,000 on the company; ₹25,000 each on two directors (₹1,00,000 total exposure)

Adjudicating Authority: ROC Delhi

Order Date: 14 January 2025

What Went Wrong?

The company was incorporated on 26 March 2021 but filed its INC-20A (Commencement of Business Declaration) only on 9 August 2021.

Before this filing, it availed a commercial loan from HDFC Bank on 16 July 2021— a clear exercise of borrowing power without obtaining the commencement certificate, which is prohibited under Section 10A(1).

The non-compliance arose mainly from procedural oversight— the company likely assumed that incorporation itself allowed business operations and financing, overlooking the post-incorporation compliance timeline.

What Could Have Been Done Differently

  • Timely filing of INC-20A: Within 180 days of incorporation, before exercising any borrowing power.
  • Internal compliance checklist: Ensuring no agreements, bank facilities, or commercial operations are undertaken before obtaining the commencement certificate.
  • Professional involvement: A Company Secretary or compliance consultant could have flagged the restriction and advised holding off the loan till post-filing acknowledgment.
  • Automated reminders: Use compliance tracking tools to flag due dates within 30–60–90-day intervals post incorporation.

How We Would Have Represented the Company

If we had represented the company, our approach would focus on:

  • Demonstrating bona fide intent: The company did not commence active business; the loan was preparatory, not operational.
  • Highlighting immediate rectification: The declaration (INC-20A) was filed within 25 days of the loan, showing voluntary correction.
  • Invoking proportionality: Under Section 454(3), the Adjudicating Officer has discretion in fixing the penalty considering nature and gravity of default.
  • Citing absence of mala fide gain: The transaction caused no loss to stakeholders or exchequer; it was a technical lapse in timing. Such an approach could have led to a reduced penalty or advisory closure under compassionate grounds — particularly for a first-year procedural default.

Learning for Professionals

  • Always verify INC-20A filing status before signing any loan or lease agreements post-incorporation.
  • Treat the Commencement Certificate as a green flag for all operational and financial activities.
  • Respond promptly to ROC show cause notices — tone and documentation can significantly influence the adjudicating outcome.
  • Maintain a compliance tracker for all post-incorporation filings (INC-20A, DIR-3 KYC, AOC-4, MGT-7A, etc.).

Professional Insight — CS Prashant Kumar

“In practice, ROC officers view Section 10A violations seriously because they touch the foundation of company operations. However, when rectified swiftly and accompanied by a transparent explanation, adjudicating officers often limit penalties to the minimum statutory figure.”

If You Receive a Similar Notice

  • Don’t ignore it. Respond within 15 days with a factual, humble representation.
  • Attach proof of compliance and rectification (like SRN of INC-20A).
  • Avoid emotional language — stick to facts, timing, and intent.
  • Engage a professional early to structure your defence and avoid escalation to RD.

References

[ROC Delhi Adjudication Order — Tejas Cargo India Limited (Order ID: PO/ADJ/01-2025/DL/00050, dated 14.01.2025)]

Was this article useful?
PK
CS Prashant Kumar

Prashant Kumar is a qualified Company Secretary with over 13 years of experience in corporate law, compliance, governance, and advisory services. He has worked with startups, SMEs, and established businesses across diverse industries, guiding them on company law matters, regulatory compliance, intellectual property, and business structuring. Passionate about simplifying complex legal and compliance processes, Prashant shares practical insights to help entrepreneurs and businesses grow with confidence and clarity.

Have a question on this?

Ask about anything in this article. Selected questions are answered here and in the newsletter.

Get the latest legal and compliance insights in your inbox

Weekly updates, regulatory alerts, practical guides and more.

WhatsApp LinkedIn
→ Index
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x